We saw what Justin looked like almost naked in Friends With Benefits, and now we know what Scarlett looks like in her birthday suit – so it’s not hard to be insanely jealous about today’s celeb news: a rumor that Scarlett and Justin may have partaken in a late night booty call just last week.

The recently divorced Scarlett (from fellow actor Ryan Reynolds) and Justin were seen partying together at New York City club 1OAK on September 14th. According to Stuff, they hung until the wee hours, drinking, getting pizza, and then heading directly to Miss Johansson’s penthouse for the rest of the night. Something tells me that the evening did not end in separate beds, especially after re-watching his music video for “What Goes Around…” that showcases some rather steamy scenes between the two (see the photo above).

Perhaps it’s just my tastes, but I would definitely put Scarlett and Justin’s late-night rendezvous on my top 5 list of “celebrity couple I’d pay to watch have sex.” Just kidding, that’s creepy*.

*Not kidding, but I am.