Like the moon landing or 9/11, we all remember where we were when the hit single Pony, by Ginuwine, hit the airwaves. Boys got boners, girls blushed in confusion, and mothers and fathers around the world gasped and said things like “America’s goin’ down the gol durn tube!” Although the song slowly lost momentum, and Ginuwine sadly died sunk into obscurity, the song lived on, randomly played as a joke at people’s birthday parties.

And now, as though the Internet planned it all along, the weirdos who still love My Little Pony (AKA Bronies) have recreated the Ginuwine music video, starring all My Little Pony dolls. And yes, it’s just as creepy as you thought.